Vladislava Stoyanova
Senior lecturer
Common Law Tort of Negligence as a Tool for Deconstructing Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights
Author
Summary, in English
This article examines how the common law tort of negligence as developed in the United Kingdom can provide a helpful guidance for deconstructing and elucidating some of the disparate analytical issues that are subsumed under the umbrella of positive obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). Both frameworks, common law and ECHR, aim to delimit the circumstances where responsibility for omissions can be found and have similar conceptual basis of protection in that they protect fundamental interests. However, in the context of common law certain analytical elements have been more thoroughly considered and more clearly articulated. These elements are: the distinction between a duty and a breach of duty; the level of foreseeability of harm; the proximity between the state and the person who has suffered harm because of an alleged omission; the reasonableness of imposing a duty; and the causation between the harm and the alleged omission. Two main arguments emerge from the juxtaposition of the ECHR analysis against the common law. First, by failing to explicitly articulate and distinguish certain analytical elements, the ECHR positive obligation judgments offer little general guidance as to the limits of responsibility in a more principled fashion. Second, the analytical inquiry applied when adjudicating positive obligations is in tension with the idea of the correlativity between rights and obligations.
Department/s
- Human Rights Law
- Public International Law
- Department of Law
- Migration Law
Publishing year
2020
Language
English
Pages
632-655
Publication/Series
International Journal of Human Rights
Volume
24
Issue
5
Document type
Journal article
Publisher
Routledge
Topic
- Law
Keywords
- Human rights
- Negligence
- ECHR
- Common law
- Positive obligations
- Mänskliga rättigheter
Status
Published
Project
- Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights: More Predictability through Better Legal Reasoning
Research group
- Human Rights Law
- Public International Law
- Migration Law
ISBN/ISSN/Other
- ISSN: 1744-053X